Ratings

[Pagodeiro]

Hi Stuttgart-man

let´s rate

it new...

A 314: 10
Chikara: 9
PI: 7
LT: 7
SOE 7,5
A7: 7
TE: 6
NPA: 6
APC: 5
Perception: 2

SOE

and LT and A 314: 9 for daytime use at work
PI and C7 and a bit of SOE .... 10 for clubbing...
TE and LT and C7

8,5 for coffee bars...
A7 and TE: 8 to get presents from your grandma and your aunt
NPA and TE 7: to build up a

sexual vibe with girls who you already know ...
APC and A314 8 for the gym...

Pago

[SyraBrian]

46 year old white male's

ratings:

Scent of Eros 8
Pheromol Factor 8
Perception 5
Alter-Ego 6
NPA 4 (8 for

effectiveness, O for odor)
Chikara 6.5

[stuttgart-man]

... and here is the

ranking of products with three evaluations at least:
(all evaluations since Matt has opened this tread)

1.

SOE............. 8.54
2. A314............ 8.30
3. NPA............. 7.98
4. A7............... 7.33
5.

A1............... 6.88
6. AE............... 6.21
7. PI................ 5.71
8. TE............... 5.67
9.

Chikara......... 4.35
10. Perception... 4.01
11. APC............ 3.10

[stuttgart-man]

to compare many products

have a big disadvantage - so can it be that a product A is rated better (average rating) than Product B although all

who have rated both has rated product B over product A! This was happend for example with A7 and NPA! Although all

who have rated A7 and NPA have rated A7 over NPA, NPA has had a better average rating!

This problem can be

avoided when comparing two products directly! This means that when comparing one products with another one, only

ratings are valid which rates both products!

As there are a big number of possible comparisons I will show only

a few comparisons (where I have thought that are the most important ones):


SOE vs Alter Ego:

rated

SOE as better: 5
rated AE as better: 3

SOE average rating: 7.63
AE average rating: 6.33


NPA vs

Alpha7:
rated NPA as better: 0
rated A7 as better: 2

NPA average rating: 6.50
A7 average rating: 8.00




SOE vs Chikara:

rated SOE as better: 10
rated Chikara as better: 2

SOE average rating:

8.04
Chikara average rating: 4.38


Edge vs NPA:

rated TE as better: 0
rated NPA as better:

9
rated TE equal as NPA: 1

TE average rating: 5.90
NPA average rating: 7.88


Edge vs Chikara:



rated TE as better: 6
rated Chikara as better: 3
rated TE equal as Chikara: 1

TE average rating:

5.50
Chikara average rating: 3.80


Edge vs Alter Ego:

rated TE as better: 3
rated AE as better:

5

TE average rating: 5.38
AE average rating: 6.39


Alter Ego vs NPA:

rated AE as better:

2
rated NPA as better: 6
rated AE equal as NPA: 1

AE average rating: 6.23
NPA average rating: 7.87




Chikara vs Alter Ego:

rated Chikara as better: 2
rated AE as better: 7

Chikara average rating:

3.39
AE average rating: 6.34


NPA vs Primal:

rated NPA as better: 5
rated PI as better: 2

NPA

average rating: 7.19
PI average rating: 5.71


SOE vs A1:

rated SOE as better: 2
rated A1 as

better: 1
rated SOE equal as A1: 1

SOE average rating: 7.38
A1 average rating: 6.88


A314 vs

Alpha7:

rated A314 as better: 1
rated A7 as better: 1

A314 average rating: 8.75
A7 average rating:

8.00


Alter Ego vs Primal:

rated AE as better: 4
rated PI as better: 1

AE average rating:

5.92
PI average rating: 5.00


SOE vs NPA:
(even if it is like comparing clasic music with heavy

metal)

rated SOE as better: 7
rated NPA as better: 2
rated SOE equal as NPA: 2

SOE average rating:

8.38
NPA average rating: 8.04

[stuttgart-man]

Old thread

- new user and new experiences - let's new rate the mones

My rating:

NPA 8
TE 8
SoE 6
Chikara 6
AE

7
LT 0

[bunk]

Brillant idea! Theres been too few

hit stories and product ratings as of late.

The past year I've been trying Impi (the blue dot one) and

depending on the situation it has been from a 6.5 to 7.5.

Girls are friendly with it on and often flirty. One of

my problems with it is I just don't enjoy the scent of it. I'm sure that one would be fixed with a different

bottle variety.

I'm placing a decent sized order sometime this week (waiting for b-nol to come back in stock)

and then I'll have plenty to play with